One Performing Tamattu‘ Going to Madinah and Then Performing ‘Umra

Question

Question: (1) An afaqi (one coming from beyond the miqats) went to Makkah the Ennobled in the months of Hajj and performed ‘Umra; after performing the ‘Umra he went to Madinah the Radiant, and on returning from Madinah the Radiant he performed a second ‘Umra, then entered the ihram of Hajj. Is his tamattu‘ valid or not? (2) Is the dam of tamattu‘ due from him or not? (3) Is any dam jabr (compensatory dam for a deficiency) due from him or not? (4) Was the tamattu‘ fulfilled by the first ‘Umra or the second? (5)

Answer

If someone, having performed ‘Umra in the months of Hajj, went to Madinah the Good and then, after returning from there, came having entered ihram for Hajj only, his tamattu‘ will be valid. This is according to Imam Abu Hanifa, in contrast to the Sahibayn (Imam Abu Yusuf and Imam Muhammad)

Source: Fatawa Mahmudiyya

Preview. The full text opens with JavaScript enabled.