Are There Abrogating and Abrogated Verses (Nasikh and Mansukh) in the Qur’an?

Question

Question: The views of Zayd and Bakr are set out below. (1) Zayd maintains that even the earlier (mutaqaddimin) scholars held that the Noble Qur'an contains certain verses whose ruling has been abrogated (mansukh al-hukm), together with the verses that abrogate them (nasikh), and that this is likewise the position of the later (muta'akhkhirin)

Answer

Answer (1) You have set out in your question the references of both sides very briefly and vaguely, and Bakr's reference in particular is mostly unclear. Had you explained the matter in somewhat more detail — that is, had you quoted the actual text of each book, [indicating] that Zayd argues from such-and-such a passage and Bakr from such-and-such — it would evidently have…

Source: Fatawa Mahmudiyya

Preview. The full text opens with JavaScript enabled.