A Second Congregation with the Original Form Changed

Question

If a second congregation is not held in the original form (hay’a ula), will it be permissible in the mosque or not?

Answer

According to one narration from Imam Abu Yusuf ﵀, it will not be makruh. However, from the zahir al-riwaya (the principal transmission of the school) it is clear that it is makruh without qualification; but between [a congregation] with the form changed and one without the form changed there will be a difference: makruh tanzihi and makruh tahrimi.

Source: Fatawa Mahmudiyya

Preview. The full text opens with JavaScript enabled.