الإفتاء

Enter a topic or fatwa name

The effect of an audible amin on the prayer of others

Question

Question: people of the Ahl-e Hadith school join the prayer in our Hanafi congregation and, after "al-Hamd", say amin loudly, in a raised voice, according to their way. Does their saying it loudly cause any defect in our prayer? And do we have the right to stop them from coming to the mosque or not?

Answer

The prayer of the Hanafis will not be spoiled because they say amin loudly. If they do not cause any trouble or discord, and on coming to the mosque simply pray in their own way, then do not stop them from coming to the mosque, and do not argue with them. The answer is correct.

Source: Fatawa Mahmudiyya

Preview. The full text opens with JavaScript enabled.

Topics

More in this chapter

Languages: English · Русский · العربية · Bosanski · Türkçe · Deutsch · বাংলা · اردو