Talaq by the words “you are haram for me”

Question

Zayd, in a state of anger and with the intention of talaq, said these words three times to his wife with whom the marriage had been consummated (madkhula): “تو مجھ پر حرام ہے، حرام ہے، حرام ہے” (“you are haram for me, haram, haram”), and: “اپنا مہر لے اور جا” (“take your mahr and go”). Will the talaq be irrevocable (ba’in) or major (mughallaza)? And is a certain respected Mufti correct in saying that after the first word she became separated (ba’ina)

Answer

[ar]الصريح يلحق الصريح ويلحق البائن بشرط العدة، والبائن يلحق الصريح. الصريح ما لا يحتاج إلى نية، بائنًا كان الواقع به أو رجعيًا. لا يلحق البائن البائن[/ar] “An explicit (sarih) talaq attaches to an explicit one and attaches to a ba’in on condition of the ‘idda; a ba’in attaches to an explicit one.

Source: Fatawa Mahmudiyya

Preview. The full text opens with JavaScript enabled.